Showing posts with label Henry VIII. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Henry VIII. Show all posts

Monday, May 15, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 3: The Trial and Sentencing

Anne’s trial took place on May 15, 1536 only 13 days after her arrest. Four of the five men accused of committing adultery with her had been tried and sentenced two days prior. Of those four men, only the court musician, Mark Smeaton plead guilty. This particular aspect is interesting in that Smeaton was the only commoner among the men and was therefore subject to torture in ways that the other were not. The torture is often cited as the impetus behind Smeaton’s “confession.”

In order to avoid a massive public spectacle and possible disturbances to the proceedings, the trial was held in King’s Hall with the Tower rather than the more traditional Westminster Hall. Anne was a massively unpopular figure among the masses. Despite the change of venue, it was recorded that there were still nearly 2000 people in attendance. As per tradition of the time, she was judged by a jury of her peers which included Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk and longtime friend of the King, Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk and Anne’s uncle, and Henry Percy, Earl of Northumberland and former betrothed of Anne. Of all of the men tasked to judge this trial, Percy was likely the most sympathetic to Anne. They had had a previous relationship, one that was thought to have been a love match. In fact, a possible pre-contract or even a secret marriage to Anne Boleyn had been given as cause for an annulment of Percy’s marriage to Mary Talbot, daughter of the Earl of Shrewsbury and cousin to the King. 

Although a detailed, formal record of Anne’s trial does not exist, we have accounts from those likely in attendance which can help us piece together what occurred. Anne would have been aware that just two days prior Brereton, Norris, Weston, and Smeaton had all been found guilty and sentenced to death. As such, one would think her countenance would be shaken. Yet by all accounts, Anne maintained a level of grace and dignity as she was brought into the courtroom and the indictment was read. She was said to have appeared in court wearing a black velvet gown with a scarlet damask petticoat. This is interesting for several reasons. First and foremost, Anne was determined to be every inch a queen. While it was certain that she would be convicted, she wanted it clearly known and understood by all witnesses that this was the Queen of England that they were sentencing. Additionally, the choice of a scarlet petticoat reinforced the innocence that she proclaimed as the color of martyrdom. The French Bishop of Riez who was in attendance would later write of Anne at the trial:  
She walked forth in fearful beauty and seemed unmoved. She came not as one who had to defend her cause, but with the bearing of one coming to great honour.

Her own uncle as the highest ranking peer on the jury would have read out the indictment which included the following: 
she, despising her marriage, and entertaining malice against the King, and following daily her frail and carnal lust, did falsely and traitorously procure by base conversations and kisses, touchings, gifts, and other infamous incitations, divers of the King's daily and familiar servants to be her adulterers and concubines… [and] conspired the death and destruction of the King, the Queen often saying she would marry one of them as soon as the King died, and affirming that she would never love the King in her heart. 
Yet despite these charges, the prosecution presented no eyewitnesses as evidence of these crimes. 


Anne was then allowed to speak in her defense. As she had no prior knowledge of the charges brought against her, there was no way for her to provide alibis or refute the 20 instances of adultery that she had been charged with. Despite her inability to provide evidence of her innocence, many of the spectators including London magistrates were persuaded of her innocence and would later remark that her guilt was simply because it had been decreed that she be gotten rid of, most likely at the request of Henry who had transferred his affections to the lovely Jane Seymour.


The decision against her was unanimous. Final sentence was pronounced by the Duke of Norfolk: 
 Because thou hast offended against our sovereign the King’s Grace in committing treason against his person, and here attainted of the same, the law of the realm is this, that thou hast deserved death, and thy judgment is tis: that thou shalt be burned here within the Tower of London on the Green, else to have thy head smitten off, as the King’s pleasure shall be further known of the same.
It was noted that when he pronounced the sentence that there were tears in his eyes. Some might say that this showed a level of compassion and affection towards his niece; however, given what we know about his character as an unsympathetic man who sought advancement above all else, these tears were more likely a sign of his relief that he had accomplished the will of the King to be rid of Anne and free to marry Jane without the marriage to Anne being held over him. This was all in spite of Henry going the extra step of having the marriage declared null and void by Archbishop Thomas Cranmer two days later. 

Anne then spoke in response to her conviction: 
I do not say I have always shown him that humility which his goodness to me merited. I confess I have had jealous fancies and suspicions of him, which I had not discretion enough, and wisdom, to conceal. But God knows, and is my witness, that I have not sinned against him in any other way. Think not I say this in the hope to prolong my life. God hath taught me how to die, and He will strengthen my faith. As for my brother, and those others who are unjustly condemned, I would willingly suffer many deaths to deliver them, but since I see it pleases the King, I shall willingly accompany them in death, with this assurance, that I shall lead an endless life with them in peace. 
This speech echoes the sentiments expressed in the disputed final letter. Anne had prepared herself for death but felt grief that Henry’s desire to be rid of her also meant that other innocent people should die. I think is perhaps one of the most telling things about her character. In this moment, she not only seems to have a profound faith in God but also compassion for others. This was not the speech of the scheming social climber that the Catholic supporters of Katherine and Mary would have history believe Anne was. Instead, this is more in line with the view of Protestants who saw Anne in a more positive light.

Once the verdict had been pronounced and Anne had spoken, Henry Percy collapsed and was carried out of the courtroom. Percy had been known to be of a weak constitution and suffer from a persisting ague. The stress of the trial likely exacerbated his illness, which would lead to his death a little over a year later.

After her own trial was completed, her brother would be tried for incest, adultery, and treason. As Anne had been convicted of having “tempted her brother with her tongue in the said George’s mouth and the said George’s tongue in hers” there was no other outcome of his trial than a conviction. The evidence of incest against George and Anne was largely based on the testimony of his wife, Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford who had been questioned by Cromwell and the royal commission about the relationship between Anne and George. 




For further reading:

Life and Death of Anne Boleyn by Eric Ives

Law as the Engine of State: The Trial of Anne Boleyn by Margery S Schauer and Frederick Shauer

Anne Boleyn: Fatal Attractions by G.W. Bernard - This particular title is interesting in that it argues that the charges of adultery against Anne were in fact true. I've read this book and find that the arguments put forth by the historian largely center around a poem by Lancelot de Carles, a servant to the French ambassador and supposed eyewitness to the trial. I find the logic and work uncompelling in its arguments, drawing false and often conflated conclusions based on rather weak interpretations of the primary sources but have included it here in the interest of providing resources on both sides of the argument.

Saturday, May 13, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 2: The Disputed Final Letter to Henry



While awaiting trial, Anne was reported to have written the below letter to King Henry VIII:

Your grace’s displeasure and my imprisonment are things so strange to me, that what to write, or what to excuse, I am altogether ignorant. Whereas you send to me (willing me to confess a truth and so obtain your favor), by such a one, whom you know to be mine ancient professed enemy, I no sooner received this message by him, than I rightly conceived your meaning; and if, as you say, confessing a truth indeed may procure my safety, I shall with all willingness and duty, perform your duty. But let not your grace ever imagine that your poor wife will be brought to acknowledge a fault, where not so much as a thought ever proceeded. And to speak a truth, never a prince had wife more loyal in all duty, and in all true affection, than you have ever found in Anne Bulen – with which name and place I could willingly have contented myself, if God and your grace’s pleasure had been so pleased. Neither did I at any time so far forget myself in my exaltation or received queenship, but that I always looked for such alteration as I now find; for the ground of my preferment being on no surer foundation than your grace’s fancy, the least alteration was fit and sufficient (I knew) to draw that fancy to some other subject.


You have chosen me from low estate to be your queen and companion, far beyond my desert or desire; if, then, you found me worthy of such honor, good your grace, let not any light fancy or bad counsel of my enemies withdraw your princely favor from me; neither let that stain – that unworthy stain – of a disloyal heart towards your good grace ever cast so foul a blot on me, and on the infant princess your daughter.


Try me, good king, but let me have a lawful trial, and let not my sworn enemies sit as my accusers and as my judges; yea, let me receive an open trial, for my truth shall fear no open shame. Then you shall see either my innocency cleared, your suspicions and conscience satisfied, the ignominy and slander of the world stopped, or my guilt openly declared. So that, whatever God and you may determine of, your grace may be freed from an open censure; and my offense being so lawfully proved, your grace may be at liberty, both before God and man, not only to execute worthy punishment on me as an unfaithful wife but to follow your affection already settled on that party for whose sake I am now as I am, whose name I could some while since have pointed unto – your grace being not ignorant of my suspicions therein. But if you have already determined of me, and that not only my death, but an infamous slander must bring your the joying of your desired happiness, then I desire of God that he will pardon your great sin herein, and likewise my enemies, the instruments thereof; and that he will not call you to a strait account for your unprincely and cruel usage of me at his general judgment-seat, where both you and myself must shortly appear; and in whose just judgment, I doubt not (whatsoever the world may think of me), mine innocency shall be openly known and sufficiently cleared.


My last and only request shall be, that myself only bear the burden of your grace’s displeasure, and that it may not touch the innocent souls of those poor gentlemen, whom, as I understand, are likewise in strait imprisonment for my sake. If ever I have found favor in your sight – if ever the name of Anne Bulen have been pleasing in your ears – then let me obtain this request; and so I will leave to trouble your grace any further, with mine earnest prayer to the Trinity to have your grace in his good keeping, and to direct you in all your actions.


From my doleful prison in the Tower, the 6th May.

This letter never reached the King. It was later found among the personal possessions of Thomas Cromwell after his arrest in 1540. There is some disagreement between historians about the authenticity of this letter. The arguments on both sides make some interesting points. 

For those who believe that this letter is a forgery, the biggest piece of evidence seems to be that the letter was not written in Anne’s hand. There are examples of Anne’s handwriting for comparison, and it is clearly not her handwriting. However, this is not necessarily the most compelling evidence for the letter as a forgery. It would not have been out of the realm of possibility that this letter was dictated to someone, most likely it would have been the Constable of the Tower, William Kingston. There has not been further evaluation of the handwriting to compare it to Kingston’s or even perhaps Cromwell himself. 

Another argument against the authenticity of the letter is that it is too familiar in tone. Because it was being written by a prisoner to the King, many historians suspect the personal tone to the letter. The tradition of the time would have dictated that a letter of this nature take a more formal tone. However, the tone of the letter would have been completely within what we know of Anne’s character. She was known to have a fiery disposition and took a very familiar tone not only with the King but others in court. In part, this characteristic contributed to her own downfall. Additionally, she would not be above appealing to Henry’s love for her as she professed her own innocence. When she had suspected that something may be afoot and Henry’s affection was waning in the days prior to her arrest, Anne had their daughter Elizabeth brought to Court. This was an attempt to remind Henry that she was the mother of his precious and precocious daughter, one who looked so much like him. 

Finally, there was also a certain level of defiance in the overall tone of the letter. This was not a woman begging for mercy and admitting to a crime. In fact, she did quite the opposite. The letter professed her innocence even before she had stood trial for the accusations laid against her. She was seeking to mitigate the situation as best she could. Not only did she protest her innocence, but she challenged Henry to give her a public trial. She acknowledged that in all likelihood Henry wanted to be rid of her and replace her with Jane Seymour. In the text of this letter, Anne alludes to this possibility. This would not be the first time that Anne had confronted Henry about his infidelity with Jane Seymour. 

Here is what we do know. 

If this letter was authentic, it never reached Henry. There could be any number of reasons of this, but it would be likely that Cromwell would have kept the letter from him in fear that it might persuaded to change his mind. 

If the letter was a forgery, it also never reached Henry. As Henry was becoming more known for his mercurial temper, it could have been written as a means of securing Anne’s fate if it seemed as though Henry might change his mind.

Of course both scenarios fit into the narrative that Cromwell helped orchestrate the downfall of Anne Boleyn due to differing views on what to do with the money that went to the Crown after the dissolution of the monasteries.

For further reading:

Anne Boleyn's Letter from the Tower: A New Assessment by Sandra Vasoli

Thursday, May 11, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 1: The Arrest and Imprisonment

So not so surprising fact: I have a fascination with Tudor history, particularly the melodrama of Henry VIII’s court and his six wives. I definitely have a favorite wife. In fact, I can rank the wives in order of interest: Anne Boleyn, Anne of Cleves, Katherine Parr, Katherine of Aragon, Katherine Howard, and Jane Seymour. As we approach the anniversary of Anne Boleyn’s death, I decided that I wanted to not only tell her story, but also give my own perspective about the events.


Before getting into the final days of Anne Boleyn, I think it would be helpful to explain why she is my favorite wife. Most portrayals of Anne showing her as a beautiful, charming seductress. The truth is that, by standards of the day, Anne was considered to be quite plain. In fact, her sister Mary was considered to be the most attractive of the sisters and had been mistress to Henry VIII before the relationship with Anne began. Tudor beauty standards dictated that women should be fair of skin, hair, and eyes. Anne was none of this. She had dark hair and eyes as well as what was described as a swarthy complexion. This is probably why I find her so appealing. It essentially wasn’t her looks that caused Henry to become infatuated. Instead, she used her intellect and wit to capture the attention of the king. 

It makes sense that this would appeal to me as I certainly do not fit into current beauty standards. She was a woman who did not depend upon her looks but rather used her mind. Anne believed that the women of Court be able to read and have access to the Holy Scripture. She kept a copy of a Book of Hours in her rooms written in French on a lectern and encouraged all of her ladies-in-waiting to read from it. Additionally, she supported the founding of universities and acted as patron to the arts. 

On May 2, 1536, Anne was arrested and taken to the Tower to await trial. Mark Smeaton, a court musician also accused had been arrested on April 30. On the same day that Anne was arrested, her brother, George, had also been arrested, having been accused of committing incest with Anne. Over the next few days, Henry Norris, Francis Weston, Thomas Page, William Brereton, and Thomas Wyatt were also arrested. Thomas Page and Thomas Wyatt would not be formally charged. While we often talk about the men and the Queen being charged with adultery, that was not the exact charge against them. Adultery with the Queen was in fact an act of high treason an enacted by the Treason Act of 1351 passed during the reign of Edward III. 

Unlike is often portrayed in film and television, Anne was not caught completely unaware by her arrest. She was first summoned to appear before a council which was comprised of the royal commissioners who had been tasked by Henry to find out about any treason that had been committed by those at court. This commission included the Dukes of Norfolk (her uncle) and Suffolk, Thomas Cromwell, The Earls of Oxford, Westmoreland, Wiltshire, and Sussex, as well as William Fitzwilliam and William Paulet. After being interrogated by the council, she was informed that she was to be arrested and then confined to her apartments until she could be transported to the tower. This transport did not begin until about two in the afternoon and so was in full daylight and thus much of London had assembled along the banks of the Thames. Anne traveled by barge to the Tower accompanied by the Duke of Norfolk, Lord Oxford, Lord Sandys (sometimes Sands), and some guards. It is believed that she entered through the Court Gate in the Byward Tower rather than through Traitor’s Gate and was greeted by William Kingston, the Constable of the Tower, upon her arrival and taken to the royal apartments where she had once stayed in preparation for her coronation. It was upon learning that she would not be housed in a dungeon but in the royal apartments she is reported to have exclaimed that this treatment was too good for her and fell to her knees in a fit of laughter and tears. This was the moment when her courage and strength of will ultimately failed. Up until this point, she was reported to have maintained a steely countenance, never showing fear. 


She would spend 13 days in the royal apartments awaiting trial. Most of her ladies-in-waiting had been dismissed. She would be served by women who had been chosen by Thomas Cromwell. These women would report back to Cromwell as to her demeanor and behavior. Additionally, Kingston kept a journal recording Anne’s time in the Tower. She was reported to sometimes fly into rages in which she would prophesy that should she be condemned, it would not rain in England. There had been a prophecy that a Queen of England would burn. Anne greatly feared this fate as the punishment for a treason, if committed by a woman, was burning at the stake unless the King chose to commute the sentence to beheading. She also asked after the others who had been taken to the Tower and accused of committing adultery with her.

For further reading:

The Lady in the Tower by Alison Weir

Wednesday, January 25, 2017

Internalized Misogyny: How Should We Frame the Story of Anne Boleyn?



Anne Boleyn, an important and somewhat controversial historical figure, is most frequently characterized as either a scheming social climber or an innocent victim of a mercurial king. As with anything, the truth is probably somewhere in the middle. What we know of Anne’s life comes primarily from two different camps with distinct agendas: Catholics loyal to Katharine of Aragon and reformers loyal to the Church of England. 

To try and find the true Anne would take more than what is typical for a blog post. However, it is not my belief that she is entirely an innocent victim, but it is also not true that she was a scheming social climber. Anne became a victim of the machinations of the court that she had encouraged. Was Anne guilty of the adultery and treason of which she was accused? By all reliable accounts, probably not. She most certainly was not guilty of incest with her brother. She was guilty of engaging in flirtations that were common at Court and ones that she had used to capture the attention of Henry in the first place. Anne grew up at the French court, one that was notorious for its lasciviousness. 

Despite that, there were no accounts of her being promiscuous during that time. The same was not true of her sister, Mary, who was also mistress to Henry VIII prior to Anne’s relationship. It makes it curious that we then associate Anne with that type of behavior. Much of that comes from the way she was discussed by Catholic sources in the historical record: the tales of six fingers on her right hand, the massive moles, and other various accounts of witchcraft. I would argue that the myth of Anne Boleyn persists as it does because of something a bit more sinister: internalized misogyny.

Part of what attracts audiences to the story of Henry VIII, Katharine of Aragon, and Anne Boleyn is that it is one we know well, and it plays out in a contemporary fashion. When we look at similar tales of infidelity in contemporary times, there is a universal reaction of the public: blame the mistress. It is rare that we ever blame the man in the situation. 

As a society, we are conditioned to believe that the unfaithful husband is only acting as any man would. It’s a “boys will be boys” attitude that men cannot be held responsible for their own behavior when it comes to sexuality. We mistakenly, and to their detriment, reduce our expectations of male behavior to its basest form. The social structure treats men as though they are slaves to their urges, animals that can’t help themselves. This is a disservice to them. Men are more than their sexual desires.

Yet, because we see men in this way, we naturally blame the other woman for infidelity. This is where the internalized misogyny often comes into play. Women are much harsher on the other woman in these types of situations. Because men cannot be held responsible for their own part in committing infidelity, it is up to women to take the moral high ground and not engage in such behavior. Women who do so are characterized as whores and sluts. When we look at the historical record regarding Anne Boleyn, particularly those from Catholic sources, she is often called “The Great Whore” or “The Great Concubine.” 

Consequently, the wife of the unfaithful husband is then characterized as the long-suffering victim of the situation. Portrayals of Katharine, both in her own time and today, are often that of the devoted wife. With this particular story, it isn’t an inaccurate characterization; Katharine was indeed a devoted wife. We have access to the final letter to Henry when she was dying in Wales. All she wished was to see him one final time. It is truly heartbreaking.

It does make it easy to blame Anne for breaking up what appeared to be a happy marriage. However, Anne was not the first instance of Henry’s infidelity. He had a bastard son with Bessie Blount, who was given the name Henry FitzRoy, a surname that indicated his position as a royal bastard, and given the title of Duke of Richmond, a hereditary title of the Tudor family. Henry had even engaged in an extramarital affair with Anne’s sister, Mary. Although not acknowledged, some of the historical record surmises that Mary’s two children, Catherine and Henry Carey, were Henry VIII’s offspring rather than Mary’s husband William Carey’s. 

Anne was just one in a long line of infatuations up until that point. What made her different was her elevation to Queen in place of Katherine. Looking at the love letters of Henry to Anne, this was primarily accomplished by her refusal to bed Henry without being married to him. In other words, it was her refusal to be a mistress that prompted Henry to seek an annulment of his marriage to Katherine and set the wheels in motion even though many at the time believed that Anne had slept with Henry much sooner than she likely did. We can be certain of some pre-marital relations as Anne was about two months pregnant at the private wedding ceremony earlier in 1533 and then about five or six months' pregnant after the annulment to Katharine and subsequent public coronation in June 1533.

Anne’s story plays into the social idea that female sexuality is dangerous. It is a consistent narrative in the Judeo-Christian world with her playing the role of the seductress. This goes back to the idea that Eve is solely responsible for original sin because she tempted Adam to also eat the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. Adam escapes culpability in early Christian theology because of the dangerous sensuality of woman. We see this echoed in other stories of the Old Testament when we look at Delilah and Samson or Jezebel and Ahab. It continues with the narrative of Mary Magdalene when she is identified as a prostitute solely based on proximity of two stories.
No, Anne Boleyn isn’t a saint, but she isn’t the villain either.