Showing posts with label Anne Boleyn. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anne Boleyn. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 23, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 7: Anne Boleyn's Legacy



When we look at the re-telling of Anne’s story throughout history, we are struck by two very different versions of this woman. Much of what we know has been shaped, not by her own writings, but by those who knew her. The Spanish ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, wrote extensively about the court of Henry VIII. As Katherine of Aragon was the aunt of King Charles of Spain, Chapuys was heavily biased against Anne. Much of the rumor and innuendo we have about Anne comes from his letters back to the Spain as he was prone to gossip. Despite his sympathy for the Lady Mary and her mother Katherine and his intense disapproval of Anne (he wouldn’t even write her name in letters, simply referring to her as the “concubine” or “putain”), he nevertheless reported that Anne was likely innocent of the crimes for which she had been executed. That being said, he did believe that Katherine of Aragon’s death was due to poison and laid much of the blame on the Boleyns, particularly Anne. 



Then there was the issue of Catholicism in England. Prior to his marriage to Anne, Henry had been a staunch Catholic, even writing a pamphlet denouncing Luther and the Protestant heresy. For this, Henry had been given the title of Defender of the Faith by Pope Leo X. Because his desire for an annulment so he could marry Anne Boleyn was denied, Henry broke England away from the Catholic Church. This schism caused a great divide in England. Rather than placing the blame on Henry, Catholics blamed Anne for this rift. She was soon characterized as a witch who had cast a spell on the King. Nicholas Sander, a staunch Catholic who sought to depose Elizabeth I and re-establish Catholicism in England, was the first record that Anne had six fingers on her right hand in 1585. Of course, this was not true. When her body was exhumed in 1876 and examined, she was found to have no physical deformities.



In direct conflict with the Catholic view on Anne, there is the Protestant view. To reformers, she was seen as a saint. Her primary biographer was John Foxe, who published his account of her story his Book of Martyrs. It was his belief that Anne’s downfall had been brought about by a Catholic conspiracy against her. He wrote that her execution had come about because:

some secret practising of the papists here not to be lacking, considering what a mighty stop she was to their purposes and proceedings, and on the contrary side, what a strong bulwark she was for the maintenance of Christ’s gospel, and sincere religion, which they then in no case could abide.

He praised her patronage of reformers like Thomas Cranmer and Hugh Latimer. In his perspective, Anne was a devout woman who had great respect for the “new religion” and believed that all should have access to the Word of God. He also believed that Elizabeth’s ascension to the throne was proof of her innocence and virtue.



During the 18th and 19th centuries, portrayals of Anne tended toward the romantic victim. To this group of historians, Anne was simply a strong-willed and beautiful woman who fell victim to her tyrannical brutish husband. This idea would persist into the latter half of the 20th century when she became less the victim of Henry and more the victim of her own ambition and intelligence. Her political and religious sympathies as well as her patronage network and influence over foreign policy put her at odds with Thomas Cromwell and others at Court. American historian, Retha Wernicke, took a less sympathetic approach, acknowledging firs the gender prejudices of the early 16th century which would have made Anne a pawn in her family’s quest for power before she became a willing participant in the power grab. There are some ideas in her work that most historians find unlikely such as the idea that George was a homosexual and part of a clandestine group of homosexuals at Court that included some of the men with whom Anne was accused of adultery as well as the idea that Anne might have been so desperate to produce a male heir that she could have been capable of sleeping with her brother to do so.



So what is the true version of Anne Boleyn? Protestant martyr? Scheming social climber? Whore? We may never know, but her story continues to fascinate. 

For further reading: 
The Rise and Fall of Anne Boleyn: Family Politics at the Court of Henry VIII by Retha M. Wernicke
The Creation of Anne Boleyn: A New Look at England’s Most Notorious Queen by Susan Bordo

Sunday, May 21, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 6: The Lady Elizabeth



After the execution of Anne, Henry became engaged to Jane Seymour on May 20, 1536. They would marry ten days later on May 30. On the same day, proceedings began to draft a new Act of Succession. The first version of this in 1533 had de-legitimized Mary as Henry’s heir and made Elizabeth his only legitimate heir. Additionally, there were provisions to place any children by Anne Boleyn ahead of Mary. Mary thus became the Lady Mary rather than Princess Mary. The new Act of Succession passed the beginning of June 1536 left Henry without any legitimate heirs. It also legitimized his marriage to Jane Seymour and made any questioning of the marriage an act of treason. This would pave the way to legitimacy for any offspring of this new marriage in terms of royal succession. 

When discussing the fallout from the execution of Anne, we can’t help but also consider its effect on Elizabeth. At the time of her mother’s death, Elizabeth was not quite three years old. Upon her birth, Elizabeth had been given her own household at Hatfield with a wet nurse and governess. Indeed Elizabeth’s half-sister, Mary, was also positioned as a servant in her household. This would all change. In the immediate aftermath of her mother’s death, much of Elizabeth’s care had been completely ignored by Henry. He had become preoccupied with his new bride. Lady Bryan, Elizabeth’s governess, would write in protest to the King about how Elizabeth had grown out of her clothes with no one to order how the new clothes should be made. At the end of June, Henry would order that the household be downsized and reorganized. Elizabeth would now only be allowed 32 servants. Mary, after a reconciliation with the King that saw her accept him as head of the Church and her own illegitimacy, would have a household restored to her and no longer served her half-sister, Elizabeth. When Jane bore Henry the long awaited son, Elizabeth’s household would once again shift as her governess, Lady Bryan, would be tasked with the care of the heir, Edward.  

One might think that she would have been unaffected by the changes given that Anne would have had very little to do with her upbringing as was royal protocol. However, Elizabeth was a precocious child even at that young age and seemed to have at least some grasp that things were not what they once were. An often told story relates how when she was told by Lady Bryan’s husband about her change in title, the toddler retorted: “how haps it, Governor, yesterday my Lady Princess, and today but my Lady Elizabeth?” There was no adequate reply as the Bryans had attempted to shield her from the events of her mother’s death as much as possible. 

For her part, Jane was kind to both of Henry’s daughters although it was reported that she preferred the Catholic Mary as she put forth much effort to have Mary restored to the line of succession after her own future children with Henry. Elizabeth was brought to Court along with Mary during Jane’s confinement and would carry the train in her half-brother’s christening procession. Just over a week after Edward’s christening and less than two weeks after his birth, Jane would die from postnatal complications. 

Overall, Elizabeth seemed to be loved by her father though removed from succession. She was educated alongside her brother, Edward, although this was likely the influence of Henry’s final wife, Katherine Parr, who had grown quite close to both Edward and Elizabeth, treating them as if they were her own children. It was finally Katherine Parr who succeeded in persuading Henry to reinstate both of his daughters to the line of succession after his son, Edward, and any potential heirs of Edward.

Throughout her life, Elizabeth was surrounded by very different depictions of her mother. For those sympathetic to the Protestant cause, her mother was a martyr, while the Catholics saw her mother as the whore who led England into sin. For her part, Elizabeth seemed to more closely identify with her father. She greatly admired him and patterned much of her own behaviors on his. Well aware of her supposed weakness as a woman, she would call upon the memory of her father for strength, having once remarked: “Although I may not be a lioness, I am a lion’s cub, and inherit many of his qualities.”

This is not to say that parallels to Anne were not apparent in Elizabeth. She is often regarded as having her mother’s spirit and intellectual fervor. Of particular interest, in this regard, lies in a family portrait from Hampton Court Palace.


When looking at the detail of Elizabeth, positioned to the far right of the main royal family grouping of Henry, Jane Seymour, and Edward, in opposition to Mary position to the far left, one notices a telling piece of jewelry on her neck. Elizabeth is depicted with a jeweled “A” necklace. 


This is significant not only because it is a clear reference to her mother’s name, it is also a piece of jewelry that had once belonged to her mother, a piece of jewelry that would be worn by Elizabeth in other portraits as well. 

For further reading:

The Young Elizabeth by Alison Plowden
Elizabeth: The Struggle for the Throne by David Starkey

Friday, May 19, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 5: The Final Hours and Execution of Anne Boleyn

After the execution of her brother and the others, Anne was set to die the next day. Like the others, her sentence had been commuted from a more painful means of execution, as a woman this would have been burning at the stake, to beheading. In his “mercy,” Henry had ordered that the Executioner of Calais be brought to England to perform the execution. This is of note particularly because this French executioner used a sword rather than an axe, which was said to be a cleaner and more precise method of execution. Decapitation by axe could often take several blows before the head was removed. 

As she prepared for death in the early morning hours of May 18, 1536, Anne had asked for her almoner, John Skip, to be summoned to the Tower for her final confession and sacrament of communion. In the presence of Skip as well as the Constable of the Tower, William Kingston, Anne once again professed her innocence of the charges with which she was charged. She did confess to not being as mild a wife as she should have been by the social standards of the day. It was then that she took the sacrament of Holy Communion. The below video, including footage from the second season of the Showtime series The Tudors, dramatizes this confession, which in the clip she makes to Thomas Cranmer, the archbishop of Canterbury. What is interesting to note in the video is that the confession itself uses some of the verbiage from the disputed letter.
 


This confession is significant. Anne would have been keenly aware that her confession would be reported back to at least Thomas Cromwell, the King’s secretary, and perhaps to Henry himself. In declaring her innocence while also submitting to the will of the King, Anne could perhaps secure her daughter’s future. Anne had resigned herself that her own death was imminent and inevitable. However, now that her marriage had been annulled and Elizabeth declared illegitimate, it was important that her paternity be questioned no further. At the beginning of the whole ordeal, there were rumors swirling that Elizabeth was not Henry’s daughter at all. It would have not been enough for her to simply declare her innocence; she must do so in a manner that could be without question. Despite her characterization by the Catholic supporters of Katherine of Aragon, Anne was considered by her own supporters as being particularly pious. To many minds, she would not have declared her innocence in the sight of God before taking Holy Communion if it had been a lie. To do so would have been peril to her soul. 

Anne continued the rest of her morning in prayer and meditation as she readied herself for death. She was scheduled to be executed about 9 in the morning. Shortly before the time of her scheduled execution, Kingston came into her rooms to inform her that the execution had been delayed until later that day. He recorded her response to this delay in a letter to Thomas Cromwell as follows:
“Mr. Kingston, I hear I shall not die afore noon, and I am very sorry therefore, for I thought to be dead by this time and past my pain.” I told her it should be no pain, it was so little. And then she said, "I heard say the executioner was very good, and I have a little neck," and then put her hands about it, laughing heartily. I have seen many men and also women executed, and that they have been in great sorrow, and to my knowledge this lady has much joy in death. Sir, her almoner is continually with her, and had been since two o'clock after midnight.
This goes to the heart of Anne’s mental state on the day before her execution. She was fully prepared to die. 

Yet, her execution would again be postponed until the next day. The Swordsman of Calais had been slowed on his journey and had not yet arrived. There wass also the possibility that further preparations needed to be made for the execution. Henry had decided that Anne’s execution would not take place on Tower Hill where anyone might be present. Instead, she would be executed within the Tower walls on the green. This more private setting would allow the demographics of the crowd to be more closely controlled for it had been decreed that no foreigners should be present. This meant that ambassadors and other dignitaries from Spain and France who were present at Court were not permitted to watch the execution. The delay in the execution would allow the Tower guards to ensure that all of the foreigners had been expelled from the premises.

On the morning of May 19th, Anne ate breakfast and waited patiently for Master Kingston to arrive to take her to execution. When he arrived at about 8 am to tell her that she should prepare herself, he found that she had already readied herself. Nothing was left to chance in Anne’s choices. She appeared much like she had at her trial. Anne wore a grey damask gown, trimmed with an ermine mantle, a crimson petticoat, and an English gable hood. 

After mounting the scaffold, she was given permission to address the crowd. This would be one of the most important moments of her life. She had to walk a fine line in order to ensure the safety of her daughter, Elizabeth. Anne could not outright proclaim her innocence and risk angering Henry, putting Elizabeth’s well-being at risk. She then gave the following speech:
Good Christian people, I am come hither to die, for according to the law, and by the law I am judged to die, and therefore I will speak nothing against it. I am come hither to accuse no man, nor to speak anything of that, whereof I am accused and condemned to die, but I pray God save the king and send him long to reign over you, for a gentler nor a more merciful prince was there never: and to me he was ever a good, a gentle and sovereign lord. And if any person will meddle of my cause, I require them to judge the best. And thus I take my leave of the world and of you all, and I heartily desire you all to pray for me. O Lord have mercy on me, to God I commend my soul.
Anne finished speaking, and her ladies removed her ermine mantle as she removed her hood and tucked her hair beneath a white cap so that it might not impede the sword. Anne would then pay the executioner’s fee after which he would ask for her forgiveness. It was then that Anne would kneel. There is some disagreement as to whether she was blindfolded or not. Most sources at the time seem to exclude the detail of having been blindfolded. 

As she waited for the blow, Anne prayed “To Jesus Christ I commend my soul; Lord Jesu receive my soul.” The executioner then called out to his assistant to fetch his sword. At this moment, Anne looked to the boy, and the executioner pulled his sword which had been hidden in the straw and struck the final blow, cleanly severing her head in a single, swift motion. 




Her body and head were then wrapped in white cloth and taken to the chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula. She would be stripped and placed in an elm chest that had once contained bow staves. It was said that she had been too tall to be placed in the chest with her head atop her neck, so it was reportedly tucked under her arm. She was then buried in an unmarked grave near her brother. 

Those who would later write an account of Anne’s final moments would comment on how calm she was. There were some that remarked that she had never looked more beautiful. She had been composed and showed no fear, except to look back at the executioner in hopes that he would not strike until she had finished.

When looking at the timeline of these events, Anne had been convicted on the 15th and originally scheduled for execution on the 18th. This would not have been enough time for a messenger to be dispatched to Calais in order to request the services of this French swordsman. This suggests that the trial had simply been for show and the sentence already determined as the swordsman would have been sent for as early as May 9th and as late as the 13th.

For further reading: 

Anne Boleyn: A New Life of England’s Tragic Queen by Joanna Denny

Monday, May 15, 2017

The Final Days of Anne Boleyn Pt 3: The Trial and Sentencing

Anne’s trial took place on May 15, 1536 only 13 days after her arrest. Four of the five men accused of committing adultery with her had been tried and sentenced two days prior. Of those four men, only the court musician, Mark Smeaton plead guilty. This particular aspect is interesting in that Smeaton was the only commoner among the men and was therefore subject to torture in ways that the other were not. The torture is often cited as the impetus behind Smeaton’s “confession.”

In order to avoid a massive public spectacle and possible disturbances to the proceedings, the trial was held in King’s Hall with the Tower rather than the more traditional Westminster Hall. Anne was a massively unpopular figure among the masses. Despite the change of venue, it was recorded that there were still nearly 2000 people in attendance. As per tradition of the time, she was judged by a jury of her peers which included Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk and longtime friend of the King, Thomas Howard, Duke of Norfolk and Anne’s uncle, and Henry Percy, Earl of Northumberland and former betrothed of Anne. Of all of the men tasked to judge this trial, Percy was likely the most sympathetic to Anne. They had had a previous relationship, one that was thought to have been a love match. In fact, a possible pre-contract or even a secret marriage to Anne Boleyn had been given as cause for an annulment of Percy’s marriage to Mary Talbot, daughter of the Earl of Shrewsbury and cousin to the King. 

Although a detailed, formal record of Anne’s trial does not exist, we have accounts from those likely in attendance which can help us piece together what occurred. Anne would have been aware that just two days prior Brereton, Norris, Weston, and Smeaton had all been found guilty and sentenced to death. As such, one would think her countenance would be shaken. Yet by all accounts, Anne maintained a level of grace and dignity as she was brought into the courtroom and the indictment was read. She was said to have appeared in court wearing a black velvet gown with a scarlet damask petticoat. This is interesting for several reasons. First and foremost, Anne was determined to be every inch a queen. While it was certain that she would be convicted, she wanted it clearly known and understood by all witnesses that this was the Queen of England that they were sentencing. Additionally, the choice of a scarlet petticoat reinforced the innocence that she proclaimed as the color of martyrdom. The French Bishop of Riez who was in attendance would later write of Anne at the trial:  
She walked forth in fearful beauty and seemed unmoved. She came not as one who had to defend her cause, but with the bearing of one coming to great honour.

Her own uncle as the highest ranking peer on the jury would have read out the indictment which included the following: 
she, despising her marriage, and entertaining malice against the King, and following daily her frail and carnal lust, did falsely and traitorously procure by base conversations and kisses, touchings, gifts, and other infamous incitations, divers of the King's daily and familiar servants to be her adulterers and concubines… [and] conspired the death and destruction of the King, the Queen often saying she would marry one of them as soon as the King died, and affirming that she would never love the King in her heart. 
Yet despite these charges, the prosecution presented no eyewitnesses as evidence of these crimes. 


Anne was then allowed to speak in her defense. As she had no prior knowledge of the charges brought against her, there was no way for her to provide alibis or refute the 20 instances of adultery that she had been charged with. Despite her inability to provide evidence of her innocence, many of the spectators including London magistrates were persuaded of her innocence and would later remark that her guilt was simply because it had been decreed that she be gotten rid of, most likely at the request of Henry who had transferred his affections to the lovely Jane Seymour.


The decision against her was unanimous. Final sentence was pronounced by the Duke of Norfolk: 
 Because thou hast offended against our sovereign the King’s Grace in committing treason against his person, and here attainted of the same, the law of the realm is this, that thou hast deserved death, and thy judgment is tis: that thou shalt be burned here within the Tower of London on the Green, else to have thy head smitten off, as the King’s pleasure shall be further known of the same.
It was noted that when he pronounced the sentence that there were tears in his eyes. Some might say that this showed a level of compassion and affection towards his niece; however, given what we know about his character as an unsympathetic man who sought advancement above all else, these tears were more likely a sign of his relief that he had accomplished the will of the King to be rid of Anne and free to marry Jane without the marriage to Anne being held over him. This was all in spite of Henry going the extra step of having the marriage declared null and void by Archbishop Thomas Cranmer two days later. 

Anne then spoke in response to her conviction: 
I do not say I have always shown him that humility which his goodness to me merited. I confess I have had jealous fancies and suspicions of him, which I had not discretion enough, and wisdom, to conceal. But God knows, and is my witness, that I have not sinned against him in any other way. Think not I say this in the hope to prolong my life. God hath taught me how to die, and He will strengthen my faith. As for my brother, and those others who are unjustly condemned, I would willingly suffer many deaths to deliver them, but since I see it pleases the King, I shall willingly accompany them in death, with this assurance, that I shall lead an endless life with them in peace. 
This speech echoes the sentiments expressed in the disputed final letter. Anne had prepared herself for death but felt grief that Henry’s desire to be rid of her also meant that other innocent people should die. I think is perhaps one of the most telling things about her character. In this moment, she not only seems to have a profound faith in God but also compassion for others. This was not the speech of the scheming social climber that the Catholic supporters of Katherine and Mary would have history believe Anne was. Instead, this is more in line with the view of Protestants who saw Anne in a more positive light.

Once the verdict had been pronounced and Anne had spoken, Henry Percy collapsed and was carried out of the courtroom. Percy had been known to be of a weak constitution and suffer from a persisting ague. The stress of the trial likely exacerbated his illness, which would lead to his death a little over a year later.

After her own trial was completed, her brother would be tried for incest, adultery, and treason. As Anne had been convicted of having “tempted her brother with her tongue in the said George’s mouth and the said George’s tongue in hers” there was no other outcome of his trial than a conviction. The evidence of incest against George and Anne was largely based on the testimony of his wife, Jane Boleyn, Lady Rochford who had been questioned by Cromwell and the royal commission about the relationship between Anne and George. 




For further reading:

Life and Death of Anne Boleyn by Eric Ives

Law as the Engine of State: The Trial of Anne Boleyn by Margery S Schauer and Frederick Shauer

Anne Boleyn: Fatal Attractions by G.W. Bernard - This particular title is interesting in that it argues that the charges of adultery against Anne were in fact true. I've read this book and find that the arguments put forth by the historian largely center around a poem by Lancelot de Carles, a servant to the French ambassador and supposed eyewitness to the trial. I find the logic and work uncompelling in its arguments, drawing false and often conflated conclusions based on rather weak interpretations of the primary sources but have included it here in the interest of providing resources on both sides of the argument.